Updated · April 2026

The compliance vendor landscape. Mapped honestly.

Most comparison pages are written by sales teams. This one is not. We sort the major compliance vendors into four categories, score them on the capabilities that actually matter, and tell you which one fits your situation. HSD wins some rows and loses others. So does every other vendor here.

Verdict in 30 seconds

If you have a security engineer who wants software, pick Vanta or Drata. If you are pre-Series A or need DPDP, pick Sprinto or Scrut. If you want SOC 2 fast in one procurement, look at Thoropass. If you do not want to staff a compliance person and you want SOC 2, ISO 27001, HIPAA, or pentest delivered as one engagement, that is HSD's lane.

§01

Four categories

Software-only platforms

Dashboards, integrations, self-service

VantaDrataSecureframeSprintoScrut Automation

These vendors sell software. The platform observes your environment, maps controls, and surfaces findings on a dashboard. Closing the findings is the customer's job, or a separate consultant's at additional cost. Polished onboarding, deep integration catalogs, and the largest review footprints in the category. The model works when there is a security engineer in-house who wants tooling, not a service.

Software + bundled audit

Single firm doing both software and audit

Thoropass

Thoropass (formerly Laika) is the notable example: one firm sells the software and performs the SOC 2 audit. The AICPA framework permits this; ISO/IEC 17021-1 §5.2.7 generally does not because of the two-year cooling-off rule. Useful when SOC 2 alone is the requirement and procurement values single-vendor accountability.

Service + platform (HSD)

Engineers ship the work, platform comes with

HSD

HSD operates differently from both above. The platform is included, but the engagement is staffed by an engineering team that owns the work to a passed audit. The total bill lands in the same range as software-plus-consultant arrangements, with one engagement instead of two procurement cycles.

Traditional GRC consulting

Audit firms and big-four advisory practices

A-LIGNSchellmanBDOCoalfireCrowe

Different category, different price point. These firms perform the audit itself and offer advisory services. They do not run software platforms. Worth knowing about for SOC 2 audit selection or when scope crosses into specialized assurance work, but not direct competitors to compliance automation vendors.

§02

Side by side

Capability	HSD	Vanta	Drata	Secureframe	Sprinto	Scrut	Thoropass
Delivery model	Service + platform	Software	Software	Software + add-on services	Software	Software + marketplace	Software + audit
SOC 2 Type 1 & Type 2
ISO 27001
HIPAA
PCI DSS v4.0
GDPR
India DPDP Act 2023
Continuous control monitoring
Engineers write your policies
Engineers close findings
MDM rollout for endpoints
AI-augmented internal pentest
Auto-remediation pull requests
Independent audit firm
Auditor coordination managed
Trust center sharing
Year founded	2024	2018	2020	2020	2020	2021	2019
G2 review volume	Building	1,000+	500+	300+	200+	100+	100+

Verified against each vendor's public pricing and feature pages, April 2026. Review counts via G2's Security Compliance category.

§03

Vendor by vendor

Vanta

The category leader. Most reviews, most polish.

Where they win

Six years in market, over 1,000 G2 reviews, broadest auditor partner network, most polished self-service onboarding. If review volume is your purchasing signal, Vanta is the safest pick.

Where they fall short

Zero remediation. Closing findings is your team's work or a separate consultant's. No penetration testing. No DPDP coverage. Pricing typically 7,500 to 25,000 USD per year for SOC 2; expect to spend 30,000 to 80,000 USD per framework with a consultant on top.

Pick Vanta when

You have a security engineer in-house who wants software, and you already have a remediation partner you trust.

Read the deep dive on Vanta

Drata

Strongest automation, similar model to Vanta.

Where they win

Higher automation than Vanta in continuous control monitoring. Strong customer success organization. Wide framework coverage. Around 500 G2 reviews. Modern UI.

Where they fall short

Same fundamental model as Vanta: dashboard surfaces findings, customer or separate consultant closes them. No bundled pentest. No DPDP. Pricing in similar 7,500 to 25,000 USD range with the same consultant overhead.

Pick Drata when

Vanta's close competitor on every dimension. Pick Drata when the automation depth matters more than review-count signal, or when sales process favors them.

Secureframe

Software-first with optional managed services.

Where they win

Added managed services in 2024 alongside the software. Strong on training and policy templates. Several hundred G2 reviews. Customers often cite the implementation specialist relationship favorably.

Where they fall short

Managed services are billed separately on top of the software subscription, so the total cost lands above HSD's bundled pricing for equivalent scope. No DPDP. No bundled pentest.

Pick Secureframe when

You want software with the option to add services later without switching vendors. The piecewise model fits some procurement processes.

Sprinto

India-built, priced for early stage.

Where they win

Lower price point than Vanta or Drata. Strong on early-stage SaaS. India operations make DPDP Act coverage natural. Good ergonomics for one-engineer teams.

Where they fall short

Smaller integration catalog than Vanta or Drata. Less mature continuous monitoring. Auditor partner network is narrower. No bundled pentest.

Pick Sprinto when

You are pre-Series A, or budget-constrained for the platform line item, or DPDP is a hard requirement and US vendors do not cover it.

Scrut Automation

Software with a marketplace of consultants.

Where they win

Hybrid model: software platform plus a curated marketplace of third-party consultants you can engage through Scrut. India operations cover DPDP. Wide framework support.

Where they fall short

Consultant quality and relationship depend on which marketplace partner you draw. Not in-house engineers. The handoff from software to consultant adds friction. Smaller G2 review base than Vanta or Drata.

Pick Scrut Automation when

You want choice of remediation partner and prefer a marketplace model over single-vendor accountability.

Thoropass

One firm, software and SOC 2 audit bundled.

Where they win

Single procurement: Thoropass operates as both the software vendor and the CPA firm performing the SOC 2 audit. Faster cycle for SOC 2 because there is no separate auditor engagement. Suits procurement teams that value single-vendor accountability.

Where they fall short

ISO 27001 still requires an independent certification body. The single-firm model concentrates conflict-of-interest risk; some procurement teams flag this. Less polished software than Vanta or Drata. No bundled remediation engineering.

Pick Thoropass when

SOC 2 is the only requirement and procurement strongly prefers a single vendor for software and audit.

§04

By situation

If you are

Pre-Series A SaaS, one security person

Pick

Sprinto or Scrut Automation

Lower price floor, simpler onboarding, one-person workflow.

If you are

Series A or B SaaS, no security hire planned

Pick

HSD

Bundled engineers eliminate the hire decision; SOC 2 plus ISO 27001 covered by one team.

If you are

Series A or B SaaS with security engineer in-house

Pick

Vanta or Drata

The engineer wants tooling, not a service; pick whichever wins on automation depth or sales process.

If you are

Mid-market with existing consulting partner

Pick

Vanta + the consultant

Dashboard plus the trusted partner is hard to beat when the partner relationship is established.

If you are

Need SOC 2 only, fast, single procurement

Pick

Thoropass

Single-vendor accountability for software and audit; ISO 27001 is a different conversation later.

If you are

India operations, DPDP required

Pick

Sprinto, Scrut, or HSD

US-headquartered vendors do not list DPDP; pick by team preference (software-first vs service-first).

If you are

Need SOC 2 + ISO 27001 + HIPAA in parallel

Pick

HSD

One team across all three frameworks instead of three concurrent procurement cycles.

If you are

Need pentest bundled with compliance program

Pick

HSD

Only vendor in this set that operates an internal pentest team and a partner network for formal engagements.

§05

FAQ

What is the difference between compliance software and compliance as a service?+

Compliance software (Vanta, Drata, Secureframe, Sprinto, Scrut) gives you a dashboard that tracks controls and surfaces findings. Closing the findings is your team's work or a separate consultant's. Compliance as a service (HSD) bundles the platform with engineers who write the policies, harden the cloud accounts, roll out the MDM, and close the findings as part of the same engagement.

Which compliance vendor has the most G2 reviews?+

Vanta crossed 1,000 G2 reviews in 2024 and holds the #1 position in G2's Security Compliance Grid. Drata is second, with hundreds of reviews. Secureframe and Sprinto each have several hundred. New entrants including HSD are still building review volume.

Do any of these vendors actually do the audit?+

Most do not. ISO/IEC 17021-1 §5.2.7 requires a two-year cooling-off period between consulting and certifying the same management system, which is why Vanta, Drata, Secureframe, Sprinto, Scrut, and HSD all coordinate independent CPA firms and certification bodies. Thoropass is an exception: it operates as a single firm doing both audit and software for SOC 2, which the AICPA framework permits but creates conflicts in ISO engagements.

Which vendor is best for an early-stage SaaS startup?+

Sprinto and Scrut Automation are priced for early-stage budgets and have lighter onboarding. Vanta is the most polished self-service experience for teams with at least one security engineer in-house. HSD makes sense if the team does not want to staff compliance work and prefers a fixed-scope program team.

Which vendor includes penetration testing?+

None of Vanta, Drata, Secureframe, Sprinto, or Scrut perform penetration tests. They refer customers to partner pentesters as separate engagements. HSD operates an internal AI-augmented pentest team for ongoing coverage and a partner network of CREST and OSCP certified human pentesters for formal certification engagements.

What does each vendor cost?+

Public pricing is sparse. Typical SOC 2 software subscriptions run from 7,500 USD to 25,000 USD per year (Vanta, Drata, Secureframe at the higher end; Sprinto and Scrut lower). Customers usually add a remediation consultant at 30,000 USD to 80,000 USD per framework. Thoropass bundles audit and software at typically 25,000 USD to 50,000 USD. HSD's bundled program lands in roughly the same total range as software-plus-consultant.

Which vendor covers India's DPDP Act?+

Sprinto and Scrut Automation, both India-based, offer DPDP Act 2023 coverage. HSD includes it in standard scope. As of April 2026, Vanta, Drata, Secureframe, and Thoropass do not list DPDP among their supported frameworks.

Can I switch from Vanta or Drata to HSD mid-engagement?+

Yes. Existing controls, evidence, and policies migrate over. The typical transition adds two to four weeks at the front of the program for evidence reimport and gap re-assessment, then HSD's engineering team picks up remediation work directly.

Which vendor has the best auditor partner network?+

Vanta has the broadest CPA firm network from six years of category leadership. Drata is second. Secureframe, Sprinto, and Scrut have respectable networks. HSD coordinates per engagement based on customer geography and industry, drawing from the same accredited CPA and certification body pools.

Which vendor wins on continuous monitoring?+

Vanta and Drata are tied for the most polished continuous monitoring with the deepest integration catalogs. Secureframe is close behind. Sprinto and Scrut are functional but with smaller integration libraries. HSD's platform covers the same ground; the engineering team differentiates more than the dashboards do.

Want this scoped for your stack?

Thirty-minute scoping call. Fixed-scope quote inside a week. We will tell you honestly if HSD is not the right pick.

Book an assessment Read the playbook